Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness (1995)

By Richard Fish
“They’re like Nirvana,” my friend John said to me when I first asked if I’d like the Pumpkins one day back in high school in 1999, and he recommended I buy their biggest selling album, the double-disc 1995 release Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. He wasn’t talking about the Buddhist state of “highest happiness” of course, but the early 90s pop/grunge band from Seattle, now so well-known in a generation’s collective memory that I’m sure they need no further introduction.
And so it was with a feeling of surprise and bewilderment that I got home and put the first disc of MCIS into my cheap hi-fi, only to hear the melodic and solemn tones of the instrumental, piano-led title track bleeding out into my teenage bedroom. I quickly learned that this band was so much more than a Nirvana sound-a-like, through the musically diverse assault of the first three tracks: the aforementioned title track, followed by the unique pop grandeur of Tonight, Tonight and the blistering metal of Jellybelly. In fact, my initial reaction to the latter wasn’t a good one: “It’s a bit too… metal,” I said to John when he said it was one of his favourite tracks, and regardless it has since become one of mine too.
The rest of the album is similarly diverse, from the more heavy rock moments like An Ode to No One to the quiet, reflective peace of By Starlight or To Forgive, and at first listening this 2-CD, two-hour onslaught can feel bloated and confusing. However, the songs are of a consistently high calibre, and the only time Billy Corgan, chief songwriter and band leader, really seems to drop the ball is with the painful Tales of a Scorched Earth. This track is essentially just blistering non-stop metal riffing and tuneless screaming through a list of insults and nonsense, for example “cause you’re all whores and I’m a fag / and I’ve got no mother and I’ve got no dad”. Charmed, I’m sure.
Of course, it is in some of these more over-the-top moments of lyrical desperation that I was able to find solace as a 16 year-old high school student. And as much as I now cringe slightly at lines like “nobody nowhere understands anything / about me and all my dreams / lost at sea” from the acoustic Stumbleine, it’s a sentiment I’m sure most of us have shared at some point in the stages of growing up.
That’s not to say there aren’t moments of joy and melodic optimism, despite what the album title may cause you to imagine. As one of the five singles to be taken from the album, Thirty-Three was largely ignored in the wake of the departure of drummer Jimmy Chamberlin due to drug charges and the death of the band’s touring keyboardist, but it still stands in the album as a unique moment, where Corgan truly epitomises just what it’s like to feel love. “I know I’ll make it, love can last forever” being one of the most charmingly reassuring lines Corgan has written, and it feels like he means it, even though his personal life may have sadly remained turbulent and unstable. Perhaps the distorted droning buzz of Love better explains how he feels: “Love, it’s who you know.”
This isn’t an album that everyone will love, and it isn’t an album that listeners will like all of straight away, but then I prefer my music that way. If there remains something to discover then I’ll be back for more. After 8 years and countless spins of these CDs, I can still listen to and enjoy the swooping majesty of songs like Muzzle and Here Is No Why and get lost in the epic seascape of Porcelina of the Vast Oceans. As an artist and songwriter, Billy Corgan has never been predictable, and it’s the diversity here which has hooked so many listeners and forced them to listen to things they might not otherwise have heard.
It was in fact the famous single Bullet With Butterfly Wings which first captivated my attention, and as I told my friend John that I really liked that “rat in a cage” song, he sort of sneered and now I understand why – it has become over-played and sadly I now find it difficult to enjoy. Perhaps it was the quiet-loud dynamics of this song that reminded me of the Nirvana I was expecting to hear when I first listened; but it’s the more the Buddhist nirvana, the happiness and enjoyment I still find through listening to this album again so many years down the line, even though my days of teenage angst and grunge are gone, that will ensure I’ll keep coming back for more.
Copyright C 2007 Richard Fish